The 1940’s were certainly turbulent if you look into the
history of mankind. Half of the world’s population were striving to gain
independence from imperialist powers and deliverance from famine while the
other half fought for all of six years over a multitude of issues. Turbulence
in Ethiopia, Spain, China and other parts of Europe led to the declarations of this
global war in which many fought and died. What earthly importance did the hilly
and difficult terrains of Afghanistan and its warring tribes have in this war? One
only needs to look into any Asian map to see the Afghans sandwiched between
India and Russia and notice a great strategic importance.
For the British, the Jewel in the Crown India was under threat.
They always feared that the Russians would find ways of wresting control from
them and presumably the Russians did have some ideas of that sort. The first
Afghan ruler who signed a treaty of friendship with Russia was Amanullah in
1921. But he was soon gone, by 1928. Nadir shah who ruled between 1929 to 1933
was wooed by both the Soviets and the British. But when the 2nd world
war started, the nature of the game changed as a third party who was present in
Kabul, gained some importance. That was Germany, and some 120 of its citizens
working in Afghanistan. Let’s go to Kabul of the 1940’s to see what was going
on. You will find all kinds of interesting people playing their cards in this
game, Subhash Bose, Hitler, Canaris, Churchill, Peter Fleming and so on…
But to get to the details, you have to first of all know
about the Abwehr, the intelligence agency which was part of the well-oiled
German war machine in those days. Abwehr was the German war agency which dealt
exclusively with raw human intelligence, obtained from field agents and other
sources. In 1939 Canaris, the head of Abwehr was tasked with planning a
Russo-German invasion of India, perhaps to be strategized only on paper to
counter the British when needed, as a threat. Hatched in Istanbul by Eppler
Gafer, it was initially unraveled in Masuleh - Afghanistan, with a fellow
conspirator Ghulam Barakatullah who had connections to the influential Mirza
Ali, the Fakir of Ipi. That operation was known by the code name Operation
Tiger and to get some perspective it is probably a better idea to start with a
previous article of mine detailing the adventurous flight of Subhash Bose from
India to Germany. Bose had planned to seek support from Hitler in his fight
against Britain and that was what took him to Berlin in 1941, where ACN Nambiar
had already set up stage. The Germans were not too receptive to the Indian
guest, to start with. Why so?
Hitler had neither the plans to invade India nor to help the
Indian legion make a charge into British held India, as Bose desired. His
intention was to take control of the Soviet Union and wait on the wings of
India to use the situation for further negotiation with the Allies in dividing
up the world. Hitler had always been clear that Indians needed to be ruled by a
superior white British government and also agreed that the Brits were doing a
good job at it (For him, the Indian freedom movement was just a rebellion of an
inferior Indian race (Asiatic jugglers) against the superior English Nordic
race! And that the Nordic race had all the rights to rule the world.). For Hitler,
the Indian congress were a waste of time and he recommended as follows to Lord
Irwin in Nov 1937 “Shoot Gandhi, and if
this doesn't suffice to reduce them to submission, shoot a dozen leading
members of Congress and if that doesn't suffice, shoot 200 and so on until
order is established. You will see how quickly they will collapse as soon you
make it clear that you mean business”. Goering supporting Hitler, quickly
labelled Gandhi an anti-British Bolshevik agent in India. But these were not
clear to Bose (though he had complained about Hitler’s remarks in Mein Kempf) and
if he had really understood all this he would never had wasted time in Berlin,
The Nazi’s had no intention of helping Bose (in reality Hitler considered hobnobbing
with people like the Agha Khan) and that was the reason why the disillusioned Bose
eventually drifted away to Japan.
But let’s get back to the Northwest frontier where Germany
had already established their place as a third power after the British and the
Russians. By 1924 the Germans were running a popular school called the Nedjat German
School in Kabul. Later, the Germans were able to sign an agreement with the Afghans
in 1937 (Todt agreement) to supervise road construction all over Afghanistan. In
1937 a Lufthansa line was established to Kabul, a Telefunken radio link was set
up and Siemens put up a 20kW broadcasting station. The few Germans were well
respected in Kabul and they were seen as more lenient towards Islam in general.
All this was fine, but the Pathans of the NWFP were restless, their rights to raid the fertile lands and people of the plains had been disallowed by the British in return for some money, insufficient as it always was (essentially economic and their implementation of their moral codes (Pukhtunwali), which imply retaliation and blood feud (Badal) in settling old disputes). Here is where you get to hear of the Fakir of Ipi or the Waziri warlord Mirza Ali Khan who rose to fame in the notorious Islam Bibi case. With his leadership Waziristan became the most notorious area of tribal unrest in the British Empire on the eve of the Second World War. Mirza Ali also provided support for Abdul Gaffer Khan’s leadership to the red shirts. They were also allied with Gandhi and Indian congress. The fakir was difficult to catch for he played a cat and mouse game, forever on the move as the scarlet pimpernel of Afghanistan.
Back in Germany, the Abwehr decided to increase their
presence in Kabul. I am sure you all remember TEL or TE Lawrence, a.k.a
Lawrence of Arabia. Well, to a certain extent it was his strategy and success
that was followed and mimicked by Hauptmann Theodor von Hippel who once worked
under him Canaris, in the formation of the Branderberger commando unit. Hippel planned
to insert élite units, meticulously trained in sabotage and well versed in
specific foreign languages, operating behind enemy lines and wreaking havoc on
the enemy's ‘command, communication and logistical’ units.
Abdul Majid, the Afghan economy minister who had traveled to
Berlin, in the meantime suggested a pact with the Germans stating that they
would support Germans against the British so that the suffering Afghans could
be liberated and in return economic support and access to the sea. Agha khan
also tried his hand at winning Hitler’s support, but failed. Anyway after a
number of subtle but failed overtures, the Abwher decided to place their agents
in Kabul. The frontline attachment 200 was to be led by Oberleutenat Dieter
Witzel Kirn (Code name Pathan) with his team of specially recruited men aimed to
establish camp near the Indian border, establish a transmitter and start radio
transmissions. He was also supposed to create a good rapport with the Fakir of
Ipi and get the people to back the Axis powers.
D Witzel |
That was the beginning of Operation Tiger. The time period
being the summer of 1941 and a time when Operation Barbarossa was being
executed with the German all-out attack on the Soviet borders. Some 4 million
soldiers were on the move, to capture the USSR and complete Hitler’s
‘Generalplan Ost’. Operation Barbarossa was the largest military operation in
world history in both manpower and casualties and was to become a major failure
when it faltered at the gates of Leningrad.
The German legation in Kabul comprised their commercial
attaché Carl Rasmuss, Dieter Witzel or The Pathan and two radio operators Doh
and Zugenbuhler. They were the people who oversaw Operation Tiger and Operation
Fuerfresser (Fire eater). The intention behind Operation tiger was to foment a
full scale uprising on the frontier and was initially scheduled for Sept 1941.
Two more agents, Prof Manfred Oberdorffer (code name Keil) and Fred Brandt
(code name Arma) were also deputed under cover of their professions namely
tropical medicine and entomology, with both purportedly working on finding a
cure for leprosy. They were tasked with establishing contact with the fakir of Ipi.
Further they had to train the locals in explosives and so on, and this was the
sub operation code named Fuerfresser. In addition to training the locals, the
so called Bose organization from Germany was to be inserted into the borders to
join the masses streaming in revolt into India against the British. That was
the full grand plan of the operation Tiger, the Grobiensatz. The Germans had an
Indian contact who would help them, that was none other than Ram Bhagat Talwar
of the Kirti Kisan party, whom I introduced in the article detailing Bose’s
flight.
Talwar was certainly a devious man and very clever one at
that, he was perhaps the most difficult to follow and a master of his trade,
that being deception and agent extraordinary. Who were his masters? British?
Soviet? German? Short, lean, handsome, fit, intelligent, able, quick witted,
cool headed and self-assured, this young fella born in the NWFP knew his
territory better than anybody. As we get into our story, this staunch communist
was all of 32 years old and known as the guide who would frequently lead his
communist friends from India to freedom, through Afghanistan. He had just
completed the task of getting Orlando Mazotta, NSC Bose through enemy hands and
sent him off to Berlin and his brother had been hanged (for assassinating the
British Punjab governor in 1930) by the British testifying his hatred for the
English. The Germans trusted him implicitly and he became their link man in
Kabul. The Abwher would pay him what he asked in return for guidance.
The Russian NKVD was a law enforcement agency of the Soviet
Union closely associated with the Soviet secret police and was known for its
political repression during the era of Joseph Stalin. It is best known for the
activities of the Gulag and the Main Directorate for State Security (GUGB), the
predecessor of the KGB. Talwar signed up with the Russian NKVD sometime after
Bose left for Berlin, perhaps in June 1941. Though the Russians were a little
leery, they finally agreed to his recruitment as agent (Code name Rom) and
explained to him that they would carefully edit and redo any document Talwar
passed on to the Abwehr agents.
In Kabul, a radio station run by Iqbal Shedai called Radio
Himalaya also broadcast daily, which Bose did not quite like as they had
different ideologies. Bose wanted a Free India radio, to rule the airs. But soon
the British learned of Bose’s presence in Berlin and made a splash stating
Boses’ fascist leaning, prompting a number of issues which hastened his
eventual departure. Bose in the meantime was appraised of the Abwehr operation
in Kabul and he was in agreement with the general idea. Bose also wanted an
airstrip to be established in tribal territory there so that the commandos and
Indian legion forces to be deployed in large numbers, since the FW Kondor transport
plane needed a long runway to land. The border unrest was in continuous foment
by the Fakir of Ipi and the British spent a lot of time fighting the Waziris. In
India, C. F. Andrews made an eloquent plea decrying the situation: "We
cannot stand out boldly for disarmament in Europe while carrying on war in
Asia."
The German attack on Russia was in full swing and the Middle
East and India were forgotten for a moment, and the Afghans were relieved to
see their hated enemy being attacked up north in Operation Barbarossa. But the
hated Soviets were soon to become members of the allies and more strongly
allied with the British. And the Afghans were in deeper trouble as they could
no longer play one against the other. As the war progressed and the invincible
German forces faltered at Leningrad, the Afghans felt cornered.
The German station Chief Hans Pilger was by now considered
too passive by Berlin and was ordered to be replaced by the outspoken Otto von
Hentig. The British would have none of it, they reacted by demanding expulsion
of all 120 or so Germans from Kabul. They also informed the Afghans that Hentig
was the man behind the earlier Shami pir folly and that Hentig should be thrown
out. The Afghans refused and the British retaliated with economic sanctions of
some sort by stopping petrol Lorries (US GM make) from plying to Kabul.While
the Hentig appointment was being hotly debated, two of our german agents in
disguise (keil and arma) and scouting for leprosy cures were caught with
ammunition and money meant for the fakir of Ipi. In the ensuing firefight ‘keil’
Oberdorffer was killed and brandt escaped. As the story of German covert involvement
became overt, Hentig remained at home and those at Kabul were ordered to lie
low and not antagonize the British. Things normalized and the Lorries with
petrol crossed the borders once again.
The situation swung in a different direction after the German
decline in Stalingrad. The Germans had gone silent in Kabul and the British ratcheted
their strength a notch.The British applied pressure on Kabul asking them to
decide who they were aligned with if they needed British support. They asked
for all Germans to be expelled from Afghanistan.
The orders for German expulsion resulted in the departure of
204 Germans and Italians by Oct 1941. Only four of the original team remained,
Witzel, Doh, Zugenbuhler and Rasmuss. Around that time another operation (somewhat
lukewarm as it turned out) code named Elephant was launched, to place agents in
Bangkok to liaise with Bengal. Nevertheless, Operation Tiger was still on the anvil,
but yet to get executed.
Back at the Russian borders, a number of Muslim Red Army
prisoners had been taken and it was an Uzbek then living in Germany (he fled
communist USSR in 1922 and moved to Berlin) named Veli Kayum Khan, heading the
operations of Operation Tiger B who was given the responsibility of recruiting
willing soldiers from the prisoners of war. The intent was to create a Muslim
regiment to fight at the Eastern front. The grand mufti of Jerusalem Hajj Amin
Al Hussayni, a friend of Hitler and Himmler, provided the jihad endorsement
(His own story is fascinating, for he was the only person close to the Nazi
warlords who was allowed to escape as Berlin fell and was never tried for war
crimes since the British (Arthur Giles) wanted him to become a leader to unite
the Palestinians. The plan to fly the FW200 Kondor aircraft with personnel was
becoming problematic and soon the plan was changed to drop them in
Turkmenistan.
Witzel continued his work diligently and the Operation B
personnel had by then been deputed to Afghanistan. Witzel reported that over
5,500 supporters of Bose had lined up in Afghanistan and 2,000 of them were
armed British military deserters. These people were training local guerilla
leaders and getting ready to fight the British. Bose in the meantime created a
number of cells operating all over India who were reporting British movements
(recall my article on the Ehrenfels?) sabotaging the railway and jute factories
in Calcutta, to name a few. But was Witzel providing correct information to
berlin?
At Kabul, Bhagat Ram Talwar, (axis code name RK) was keeping
Berlin informed of various developments. The Italians in Kabul provided some
amount of training to the Indians who had gathered, like Talwar, Sodhi and
Ganguly and who sent their own reports to Berlin and Bose. In the meantime RK
obtained more and more money from the Nazis while providing them faked reports
purportedly from Bose’s organization in Bengal. The reversals in Russia and
other events resulted in Operation Tiger being postponed several times. Bose
had in the meantime moved to Japan and Singapore had fallen. The Japanese march
through Assam into India was now a definite possibility.
Rassmuss gave Talwar all the money and wireless equipment demanded,
but he would faithfully turn them over to the NKVD. The complete details of
Axis activity gleaned by Talwar was thus passed on to the Russians. The NKVD
also tested Talwar often to see if he could handle a double agent stress. Well,
as we will soon find out, he was not just a double agent, but a quintuple agent
(remember that he had a number of dealings with the Italians as well) .The NKVD
asked Talwar to shed off his communist leanings
Uttam Chand was the shop owner in Kabul who provided housing
to the Indians. He was soon picked up by the Afghans when his British passport
expired and expelled to India where he was promptly arrested by the English. Harminder
Singh Sodhi had in the meantime become an agent for the Soviets providing whatever
he knew to the Russians and focused on heading the communist Kirti party’s work
in India based on Soviet instructions rather than Bose’s or axis. He was also
arrested by the British soon after. So as we see, Talwar, alias Rahmat Khan
alias Ram was soon all alone.
In Jan 1942, the Abwehr airdropped 100 trained Indians from
the Indian legion into an area deep in East Iran. Their mission was to reach
India via Baluchistan and carry Sabotage acts and eventually prepare a national
uprising. This was code named operation Bajedere. In March 42, Witzel asked Berlin
for permission to commence preparations for Operation Tiger by visiting the borders
and starting training of tribesmen. He got it only in June, but it resulted in
nothing under watchful eyes of the Afghan police. Meanwhile the fakir of ipi
was having his own tussles with the British and kept on demanding money from
the Talwar in return for his support. Talwar
in the meantime gave the Nazis fanciful accounts that preparations for a major
revolt in the tribal areas was well underway. He also made a request for sabotage
material (while at the same time ditching dynamite supplied by the Italians)
and half a million Duetsche marks to bribe the Fakir of Ipi. Ribbentrop from
Berlin approved a million! Things were coming to a head.
In June 1942, the NKVD’s Ovakimyan met with SOE’s George hill
to discuss mutual cooperation and to work jointly against the Germans, perhaps
fearing that Uttam chand and Sodhi would talk and reveal Bhagat Ram talwar’s
role in Kabul. For the first time in history two secret agencies agreed to
share Talwar, the double agent. The NKVD in return wanted information on Japans
moves against China.
We mentioned that Talwar was a multiple agent. We know
already that he worked for the Italians, the
Germans and the Soviets. Who else
did he work with? Here enters a very interesting man, a writer who strayed into
the activities of the SOE, none other than Peter Fleming who had come to join
the Indian raj as the head of the SEAC’s deception division. Peter frequently
used AIR radio broadcasts to convey secret messages. The stock trade of the DIB’s
SEAC was manipulation of double agents. (Peter’s brother was Ian Fleming who
later wrote all the 007 James Bond books – so now you know where the inspiration
came from). Peter was given charge of running Talwar and that was how quad
agent Silver was created.
Silver and Fleming got to work, the ensuing reports fed to the
Germans claimed that Bose’s organization in India was massively supported and
leady to leap in support of the Germans! Fictitious organizations like the All
India national revolutionary committee and the Provisional central committee
were mentioned.
RK or Talwar was already a quad agent, but the reason why
the Abwher used his dispatches so implicitly needs a little diverse thought. Interestingly,
Witzel and Rasmuss did not pass this on to Berlin and focused on sabotage and
other similar efforts. However Silver’s demand for 5,000 pounds to start a
wireless link between Delhi and Berlin was quickly complied with. Many more similar
monetary demands resulted in Silver collecting a considerable fortune. Why did
the Germans not pass on all the information? Perhaps they had their own
suspicions about the facts and were using his dispatches only to cling on further
their own careers.
Soon after all this, the British arrested all the German
agents (perhaps with Talwar’s help) and activities ceased. In 1943, Witzel and Doh
were released under a British guarantee of safe conduct. Rassmuss fled (after the
NKVD tried to recruit Rassmuss) through India. Pietro Quaroni the Italian later
exposed the full Axis network in Kabul to the British, in his testimony. The
soviets in the meantime also told Rassmuss about Silver being a multiple agent.
But Talwar continued his trips to Kabul and kept in touch with Witzel who was
back in Berlin. We do not know for sure if Rassmuss worked for the British
while in India following his flight from Kabul, but he certainly did not tell
Berlin about Silver.
Nothing more was done with respect to the originally planned
NWFP operation. And with that came an end to Operation Tiger or the German plan
to invade India through the NWFP.
The winter of 42 was when Emile Schenkl delivered Bose’s
daughter. Things were turbulent in India, his people were starving and Bose was
upset that in this critical juncture, he could not travel to India. So after
handing over Azad Hind to ACN Nambiar, he left for Japan in the U boat 180.
Canaris fell afoul of Hitler for various reasons. The Abweher
was abolished and Canaris was arrested on 23 July 1944, in the aftermath of the
plot against Hitler and executed shortly before the end of the war, along with
Oster, his deputy. As we all know, the Axis powers lost the war and all the surly
characters met with just ends.
Peter Fleming returned to Britain and did other things, but
whenever his feet touched the magnificent tiger skin which adorned his study
floor, he remembered his grand times in Delhi. I do not know if he ever
remembered Silver.
Silver’s complete story is not detailed here, for there is
so much more, and can be a book by itself. In any case, what happened to him? As
Mihir Bose explains in his article ‘Everyone’s man in Kabul’ - In 1976, when Bhagat
Ram wrote his autobiography, aware that Bose was now a hero of India’s freedom
struggle, Silver decided he could not tell the truth. He wrote of Quaroni and
Rasmuss but there was no mention of the Russians, Fleming nor of his nickname,
Silver. This most remarkable spy carried that secret to his grave
Bose it appears, sadly knew nothing about Silvers deception
and vanished in 1945…
Dietrich Witzel, code name Pathan, was later involved in the
UPA movement in Ukraine, leading the FAK 202 and was awarded an Iron Cross.
Later known under the name Dietrich Kirn, he became a writer of some repute.
After the Germans were expelled from Kabul, a period of mutual
cooperation continued between the USSR and UK against Nazi Germany until the
end of the war in 1945.The Fakir of Ipi continued on, even though Quaroni himself
admitted to his British interrogators that he had realized during the summer of
1941 that the Axis plans to use the Faqir of Ipi were a sheer waste of time and
money. After Partition the Fakir turned into the most vehement tribal opponent
to their Pakistan takeover. The Fakir made a series of overtures to Pandit
Nehru, whom he allegedly addressed as 'King of India’ - but to no avail. In1954
his Commander-in-Chief, Mehar Dil, surrendered to Pakistan and this brought the
Waziristan insurrection to an end. The Fakir of Ipi passed away in 1960.
Afghanistan continues to be a place where intrigues are
wrought, wars are fought and death can be seen every day, even today. As Lord
Curzon once said: 'I do not prophesy about the future. No man who has read a
page of Indian history will ever prophesy about the Frontier……………….
References
India in Axis strategy – Milan Hauner
Dealing with the Devil: Donal O'Sullivan
The Deceivers: Allied Military Deception in the Second World
War- Thaddeus Holt
Subash Chandra Bose in Nazi Germany – Romain Hayes
The Brandenburger Commandos: Germany's Elite Warrior Spies
in World War II
Franz Kurowski
Raj, Secrets, Revolution: A Life of Subhas Chandra Bose -
Mihir Bose
The Jew is Not My Enemy: Tarek Fatah
Notes:
- History will refer to two Operation
Tiger’s annals, and there is another little known Operation Tiger from the
WW II. It was a botched US rehearsal of the D Day landings at Normandy,
carried out at Slapton Sands in the UK. Due to an error in transmitting
frequencies, the Germans picked up the radio signals and US forces were
attacked by German E boats who saw they had no escorts. Close to 800
sailors and soldiers were apparently killed and the story was hushed up.
- Shami Pir folly - A number
of Wazirs cross the Afghan frontier with the object of looting and of
stirring up a rising against the reigning Afghan house as a result of an
agitation headed by Syed Mohammad Sadi or Shami Pir (Syrian imam), a
priest from Damascus whose family was connected with the ex-king
Amanullah. After collecting a British bribe, Pir went back to Europe.
5 comments:
Always a pleasure to see a new post on this blog. Should compile into a book- maybe an Ebook with 'smart links' or whatever it is called.
Two points-
1) You write 'Well, to a certain extent it was his strategy and success that was followed and mimicked by Hauptmann Theodor von Hippel who once worked under him, in the formation of the Branderberger commando unit. ' In context it looks like you are saying Hippel worked under TEL not Canaris.
2) The story of Aga Khan promising 30,000 Arabs to Hitler is proved to be based on forged document. This is a sensitive issue and has a religious dimension. I don't say that it is unimaginable; just that there will be never any evidence of it because the personage in question was highly astute. No doubt, he had property in South of France to protect and also, without question, he needed to hedge his bets; still Aga Khan was not a fanatic type- like Husseini- and looked down on Hitler as a low fellow.
One suggestion- why not put in 'hyperlinks' or whatever it is called?
I am saying this because you unfailingly hit upon really interesting personalities and events in your blog post. I realize this is just a leisure activity for you- still, you write better than many professionals.
I always like it when you mention personal connection, or reason for interest, in the topic of the post. Sometimes the post may be sad- in that case your readers send their good thoughts for you and each other.
Nambiar would be a fine subject for a chapter in a book which takes ten or twelve Malylalee people born at about the same time, in the same area, and traces their different trajectories.
God's own country shows God is a veritable Shakespeare when it comes to creating contrasting characters and destinies out of the same potter's clay!
My own ancestral Kumbhakonam sadly, though producing good people during the same period, has much less human interest.
Thanks windwheel,
always a pleasure to read your astute comments
My source on the Aga Khan involvement was the masterful book on the subject of India and the Axis powers written by Milan Hauner.In page 65 he explains that Aga Khan, who found Hitler and Goering almost charming, in a letter to the Times of 5/11/77 expressed doubts as to whether Hitler really meant what he had said (about India) in the Mein Kempf. In page 215 he mentions about Khan’s meeting with Price Max Hohenlohe in 1940 where he mentioned of a pact with the Kehdive of Egypt about them agreeing to drink a bottle of champagne on the first day Hitler spent at the Windsor castle. He also assured that his followers and several young maharajas would help the axis powers in administering India after Italay and Germany had taken over from the British. However both Ribbentrop and Hitler issued separate instructions in 1940 and 1941 to break of contacts with the Aga Khan. Hauner’s own sources are provided in the book. I do not refer to the 30,000 soldier story recently stated in the daily mail, citing information from the Kew National archives.
Thanks for the comment on Hauptmann Theodor von Hippel, you are right, the him is Canaris, duly corrected.
I wrote about ACN Nambiar many years ago - http://maddy06.blogspot.com/2009/01/nambiar-bose-germany.html and Champaka Raman Pillai as well http://maddy06.blogspot.com/2009/07/champaka-raman-pillai-forgotten-freedom.html
I will soon compile an ebook, am working on creating a compilation..
Long gap between blogs, I dont like it. Write more often pls.
thanks sankarasubramaniam..
i would like to do so too..but with little time during week ends and studies in the evenings, i can just about manage these.. will definitely try to increase the frequency..
Hi Maddy,
How r u ?
Another brilliant article; i knew only about Russians in Afganisthan & knew not much of the German acts there. So thanks for all these info. Could u also post the link to ur other article on Bose ? Thanks.
Agree with Shankara Subramanian's sentiments above....
Post a Comment